City of Charlotte CATS Bus Rear-Ends Handicapped
Accessible Van at Stoplight Jury Awards over $1 Million

City of Charlotte CATS Bu…

City of Charlotte CATS Bus Rear-Ends 
Handicapped Accessible Van at Stoplight 

Jury Verdict:

$800,000 – Compensatory Damages +

$239,193 – Interest from the Date of Filing

$250,000 – Punitive Damages +

$89,315 – Interest from the Date of Filing

$26,822 – Cost Reimbursement



Brief Statement of Claim:

City of Charlotte bus rear-ended handicapped accessible van that was stopped at a red light at an intersection; jury verdict of $800,000 in compensatory damages; interest from the date of filing $239,193; jury verdict of $250,000 in punitive damages; interest from the date of filing $89,315; costs $26,822.

Principal Damages:

A female in her 70s who was confined to a wheelchair as a result of muscular sclerosis but had full use of her arms sustained severe permanent injuries to her shoulders which caused her severe limitation in the use of her arms.

Trial or Settlement:

Trial (and Appeal by Defendants)

County where Tried or Settled:


Case Name and Number:

Springs v. City of Charlotte, et al., 07-CVS-11908

Date Concluded: 

Judgment dated August 15, 2008; compensatory damage award affirmed by Court of Appeals on January 18, 2011; punitive damage and cost award affirmed by Court of Appeals on August 7, 2012.

Attorneys for Plaintiffs:

T. LaFontine Odom, Sr. (trial and appeal), Thomas L. Odom, Jr. (trial and appeal) & David W. Murray (appeal), The Odom Firm, PLLC of Charlotte, North Carolina.


Click "Read more" to view the video. Read More
Attorney David Murray obtained a decision from the Mecklenburg County Superior Court reversing a City of Charlotte Zoning Board of Adjustment (“ZBA”) decision which found his client in violation of the City of Charlotte Zoning Ordinance for its o… Read More
Attorney David Murray applied his knowledge of property law and land valuation to obtain a 1.7 million dollar settlement for his clients against a developer who he believed was violating the restrictive covenants on and around the landowners’ p… Read More
Eminent domain is the government’s power to take private land for public use. This power stems from the Fifth Amendment to the Constitution, so although it may seem like the government is overreaching when it tries to take your land, this right… Read More
Your land is yours — or so you thought. Then you received a letter from the government informing you that it is taking your land through the power of eminent domain to expand an airport, for a public utilities project, or some other use. Your first… Read More