Auto Repair Man Sues Customer for Repair Bill Results in Customer Filing
Counterclaims for Damage & Loss of Use of Auto Jury Awards over $300,000 to Customer

Auto Repair Man Sues Cust…

Auto Repair Man Sues Customer for Repair Bill – Results in Customer Filing Counterclaims for Damage & Loss of Use of Auto

Jury Verdict:

$60,000 – Damage to Auto & Loss of Use (Auto Valued at $20,000)

$17,000 – Award of Attorneys’ Fees

$250,000 – Punitive Damages


$327,000

 

Brief Statement of Claim:

Auto repair sole proprietorship claiming to be a "pure trust" filed action and claimed materialman and possessory lien for repairs to auto; consumer counterclaimed for unlawful repair charges and lien fees, unfair and deceptive trade practices and punitive damages; Judgment on counterclaim of $20,000 trebled to $60,000 and attorneys’ fees of $17,000; Jury verdict of $350,000 on punitive damage claim reduced to $250,000; Fraudulent Deeds of Trust and transfer of assets to "Pure Trusts"; consumer/creditor put Plaintiff/debtor into Involuntary Bankruptcy; Trustee appointed; Fraudulent Deeds of Trusts and transfers to be set aside and sale of assets by trustee; Settlement of $360,000.

Principal Injuries:

Damage to auto and loss of use for over one year while Plaintiff held the auto of $20,000.00 (trebled) to $60,000.00 and award of attorney fees of $17,000.00; punitive damage verdict of $350,000.00 reduced to $250,000.00

Trial or Settlement:

Partial Summary Judgment and trial in District Court and settlement in Bankruptcy Court.

County where Tried or Settled:

Mecklenburg

Case Name and Number:

Burton v.Hobbs, 00-CVD-5450 (Mecklenburg County); In re: Burton, 02-3259 (W.D.N.C.)

Date Concluded:

May, 2004

Insurance Carriers:

N/A

Attorneys for Defendant Beverly Hobb:

Thomas L. Odom Jr., The Odom Firm, PLLC of Charlotte.

News

Nov
19
Click "Read more" to view the video. Read More
Oct
15
Attorney David Murray obtained a decision from the Mecklenburg County Superior Court reversing a City of Charlotte Zoning Board of Adjustment (“ZBA”) decision which found his client in violation of the City of Charlotte Zoning Ordinance for its o… Read More
Oct
1
Attorney David Murray applied his knowledge of property law and land valuation to obtain a 1.7 million dollar settlement for his clients against a developer who he believed was violating the restrictive covenants on and around the landowners’ p… Read More
Apr
16
Eminent domain is the government’s power to take private land for public use. This power stems from the Fifth Amendment to the Constitution, so although it may seem like the government is overreaching when it tries to take your land, this right… Read More
Apr
10
Your land is yours — or so you thought. Then you received a letter from the government informing you that it is taking your land through the power of eminent domain to expand an airport, for a public utilities project, or some other use. Your first… Read More